Google is beginning to have a subtle, but noticeable effect on research. More and more scholarly publications are putting up their issues in PDF format, which Google indexes as though they were traditional Web pages. But almost no one is publishing entire books online in PDF form. So, when you're doing research online, Google is implicitly pushing you toward information stored in articles and away from information stored in books. Assuming this practice continues, and assuming that Google continues to grow in influence, we may find ourselves in a world where, if you want to get an idea into circulation, you're better off publishing a PDF file on the Web than landing a book deal.
The problem with this argument is that it fails to recognize that this process predates Google -- or the Internet, for that matter.
Johnson sets this up as an either/or question -- online papers or books. In point of fact, for most academics this is a progression. First you circulate your ideas in draft form, then as a conference paper, then as an article, and then -- maybe -- publish a book. The book stage depends on the discipline -- for example, they matter far less in economics than in political science. However, this was true long before Google. The only thing the Internet and its search engines has changed is widening the access to papers at the preliminary stages of development. [But what about writers not affiliated with universities?--ed. I'd argue that the process is similar. Good writers/researchers often publish the germ of an idea in a magazine before deciding that it has enough legs to merit writing a book. Often, the author will publish excerpts from the book in magazines or journals. For example, Michael Lewis published an excerpt of Moneyball in the New York Times Magazine this March. This applies to fiction-writers as well.]
Furthermore, there are good reasons for the process to work this way. Getting an idea/argument out in draft form has two advantages to just writing a book without posting or publishing bits of it online. First, for the author, making the ideas available in draft form permits greater feedback, which in turn helps to improve the ideas. Second, for the community of people interested in the topic, finding such ideas as early as possible lets them stay on the cutting edge of the latest work on the subject (it certainly helps with bibliography-hunting).
Is Johnson correct that with Google, fewer people prefer to read a researcher's book-length treatment of the topic over the Internet-accessible, condensed version of the argument? I doubt it. Busy people look for shortcuts, and a big shortcut for scholars is to read an author's article instead of his/her book (unless the topic or argument really hits home). This was true long before the Internet or Google ever existed.
UPDATE: For another critique, click here and here. Johnson responds ably on his blog. He's all-too-correct in observing:
It's a sign of the times I suppose that a piece about search engine algorithms comes across as an incendiary, hot-button assault...
ANOTHER UPDATE: Larry Solum over at Legal Theory Blog has an extended discussion of the Internet's effect on legal research.
Linkadoodles
- Real Dan W. Drezner
- Toothing
- Academic Secret
- African Food Blog
- Genius Duck
- Blogopoly
- Second String Swap
- Work at Home News
- Bashhh
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Dip Dot
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- iPhone News iPad Review
- Cheap Hotels Travel
- Retirement Planning
- Intelligence Online
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(459)
-
▼
July
(49)
- LOOKING FOR ANSWERS?: I'll be posting my thoughts...
- MY GIFT: Today is my brother's birthday -- sort o...
- DEBATING THE CAUSES OF WAR: Josh Marshall and Ste...
- AFGHANISTAN ROUNDUP: A few months ago I expressed...
- A DEFENSE OF ASHCROFT: The elite consensus is tha...
- IRAQ ROUNDUP: In the wake of the Hussein boys' de...
- THE LATEST FALLOUT FROM NORTH KOREA: I've been re...
- INTERNET RESEARCH ADDENDUM: Henry Farrell respond...
- THE POLITICIZATION OF INTELLIGENCE: Josh Marshall...
- RESPONDING TO MY CRITICS: Catching up from a week...
- OXBLOG VS. THE NEW YORK TIMES: David Adesnik's re...
- PROSE ENVY: Tyler Cowen is correct to praise Mic...
- THE OFFICIAL ATTACK ON PALESTINIAN INTELLECTUALS: ...
- STEPHEN JOHNSON IS NOT AN ACADEMIC: In a Slate es...
- WORTH READING: David Adesnik's critique of the Wa...
- LET THEM EAT SUBSIDIES: That's the title of my la...
- LET THEM EAT YELLOWCAKE: I understand why Josh Ma...
- COURAGE: ESPN's ESPY awards show -- which airs th...
- DREZNER GETS RESULTS FROM THE CHICAGO TRIBUNE!!: ...
- QUOTE OF THE DAY: Courtesy of Tyler Cowen, a semi...
- THE JOSE BOVE FOLLIES: Back in November, I blogge...
- DEBATING THE REGULATION OF ANNOYANCE: I'm quite c...
- MEET THE IMF'S NEW ECONOMIST: Earlier this month,...
- TWO TAKES ON BLOGS: Kathleen Parker takes to the ...
- NEW YORK TIMES UPDATE: Bill Keller has been named...
- THE GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS ABOUT PALESTINIAN POLIT...
- UGANDA, BOTSWANA AND AIDS, REDUX: This Financial ...
- AND THE CROWD GOES WILD!!!: The blog just topped ...
- PAT ROBERTSON ACTING LIKE A FOREIGN POLICY DUMBASS...
- JOHN B. JUDIS, MEET LEON TROTSKY: In Salon today,...
- HOW AFRICA CAN HELP ITSELF, CONT'D: Yankee Blog, ...
- IRAN ROUND-UP: Alas, I was too busy with other th...
- I'M ONLY POSTING THIS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES: K...
- HOW AFRICA CAN HELP ITSELF: Given the spate of re...
- GOOD NEWS IN AFGHANISTAN: I've been pessimistic a...
- PEACEKEEPING INSTITUTE TO STAY OPEN: In April I b...
- DEMOCRATS AND FOREIGN POLICY: Looking for links o...
- TAKING HOWARD DEAN SERIOUSLY: My latest TNR essay...
- VOLOKH AND BAKER: Eugene Volokh responds to the D...
- CAN DUSTY BAKER TAKE THE HEAT?: Dusty Baker -- th...
- THE 2003 HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT: The Human Deve...
- SHOWDOWN IN THE OCCUPIED TERRITORIES: Palestinian...
- NEW BLOG OF NOTE: A month ago I posted some recom...
- VIRGINIA POSTREL WANTS TO STEAL THE BLOGOSPHERE'S ...
- EXPLAINING BUSH'S DARE: David Warren ventures an ...
- THE MANPOWER CRUNCH: That's the conclusion of Fre...
- EMERGING FROM THE VACATION COCOON: As I have prev...
- A WRAP-UP OF MY WORKING VACATION: For those who c...
- BACK IN CHICAGO: But waaaaayyyyyy too jet-lagged ...
-
▼
July
(49)
0 comments:
Post a Comment